Black & Anthracite Citys

[lolasmom]

Is it stupid to keep both, black and anthracite since they are dark and kind of similar?

 

[jenny70]

My personal opionion, NO!!! I have an 08 Anthracite first and a 07 black City, the colors are completely different.

 

[Nat_CAN]

Can you post picture side by side so we can see the color difference?

 

[lolasmom]

Sorry I can't at this time. I wish I could ;(

 

[cate.louvre]

I have an '07 black City and an '09 anthracite Giant Work and the colours are indeed very different. I'm with jenny70 - keep 'em!

 

[beauxgoris]

I have 4 black bal bags. So if you love them then no it's not stupid. Between the two (if you had to choose) I'd stick with black = classic and timeless.

 

[HandbagAngel]

Which year's Anthracite you have? If it is 2007 Anthracite, I vote for keep the Anthracite since it is such a unique and stunning color; otherwise, keep the Black.

 

[pinkboudoir]

If you love dark colours, nothing would stop you from having a whole lot of them. If you like colours like me, you probably would only want ONE dark/neutral coloured bag.

 

[jenny70]

I completely agree with this statement: Black = Classic & Timeless!!

I have 4 black bal bags. So if you love them then no it's not stupid. Between the two (if you had to choose) I'd stick with black = classic and timeless.

 

[heather123]

Although Black and Anthracite are similar there are very striking differences between the two shades. Today I had a sky blue nylon carrier bag in my Anthra Twiggy, to hold purchases from local shops. When I looked at it next to the Twiggy there was no way anybody would have thought my Bbag was black! So it certainly wouldn't be stupid to keep both bags!

 

[bpurse]

I say keep them both. I have a black city and have ordered a anthra city from Erica I'll get next month. They are two very different and timeless colors.

 

[lolasmom]

Thanks Girls. I'm keeping them both.

 

[jenny70]

YAY!!

Thanks Girls. I'm keeping them both.

 

[cbarrus]

I also have a black City and an '07 anthra City. They are very different to me, so I think keeping both is a good choice!

 

[crazyaboutbags]

No, that's not stupid at all, one is black and the other grey IMPO, they are different, so keep both. Good luck!