Big Whistle or Small Whistle???

[SwankyMama]

There's one at my Saks in blueberry; The leather has the smoothest and most buttery feel with just a hint of shine. It's the big whistle but I think it might be a tad too large, if anyone has either or please feel free to express your thoughts on this bag!

 

[Pewter]

I don't have one but I like the longer, more rectangular one more than the taller, boxier one, if that makes any sense. I bet that bag would be gorgeous in blueberry though!

 

[SwankyMama]

It is beautiful pewter!

 

[SwankyMama]

Ladies feel free to comment!

 

[ashley_brook]

I love the whistle bags, I think they are really cute. I am surprised that no one here has one(?) I actually posted a new thread awhile back to see if anyone had one because I wanted to see pics. No responses. Just people wrote that they liked the style but didn't have one. It seems that most of us on the forum are resistent to change. (Giant hardware and whistle bags)

I think the size seems fine. It kinda box-y but its a lot smaller then something like the Day.