Best peach lipstick without a chalky white base?

ProfNot

Sylvie Guillem fan
O.G.
May 10, 2006
2,553
72
danceland
Hi, Ladies

I have been trying to find a peach lipstick or lip tint that does not show a chalky-white base on my lips!

Most peach or coral lipsticks have too much blue - a slightly purple tint to them from too much blue in the beige base. So when I find a nice peach, I get excited until I put it on my lips and it turns chalky white. Yuck.

My next try is Kylie Cosmetics dirty peach lip pencil and liquid lipstick kit. Any feedback or tips about this one?

I'm a natural redhead with fair skin and I want a nice soft peach for spring. Is that too much for a girl to ask?

Thanks for your help!
 

Miss Krys

Member
Jun 14, 2014
3,992
3,195
Edmonton, Canada
Hi, Ladies

I have been trying to find a peach lipstick or lip tint that does not show a chalky-white base on my lips!

Most peach or coral lipsticks have too much blue - a slightly purple tint to them from too much blue in the beige base. So when I find a nice peach, I get excited until I put it on my lips and it turns chalky white. Yuck.

My next try is Kylie Cosmetics dirty peach lip pencil and liquid lipstick kit. Any feedback or tips about this one?

I'm a natural redhead with fair skin and I want a nice soft peach for spring. Is that too much for a girl to ask?

Thanks for your help!
Have you looked at Too Faced's Sweet Peach line? Their lip gloss - I have the colour Papa Don't Peach - is beautifully pigmented and stays on my lips better than some MAC lipsticks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fendifemale

fendifemale

MCM is bae!
O.G.
Oct 10, 2005
4,575
1,673
texas
I have Papa Don't Peach. It's not chalky. I also have WetnWild Peachy Keen and it's not chalky either.
 

gazoo

O.G.
Aug 26, 2006
8,596
2,062
US
Tom Ford Nude Vanille comes up peachy on me. It's beautiful, I get random compliments on it from strangers.
 

Tracy

shallowly obsessing
Moderator
O.G.
Sep 30, 2007
12,935
44
Diot Addict Extreme Saint Tropez
Shiseido Perfect Rouge lipsticks: PK343 & PK249
 

mrskolar09

loves her Lab
O.G.
Oct 28, 2009
1,191
345
Pennsylvania
I've never tried the Kylie Dirty Peach color, but I do have another one of her lip kits and I was impressed by how true the color was to how it appeared in the tube. The quality was a pleasant surprise as well. As far as peaches go, I don't wear them well so I tend to avoid them but I though that the Too Faced peach line had some beautiful true peach colors.
 

Amazona

Crazy bird lady
Mar 31, 2013
2,889
2,696
Finland
A pale-skinned redhead here as well, and my favorite is MAC Shy Girl. It's a peachy nude with a little shimmer; looks good and doesn't give off that nasty chalky look. Another favorite is a Max Factor tinted lip balm. My forever love in this category is Stila Kitten gloss, though. It's THE perfect color!
 

Amazona

Crazy bird lady
Mar 31, 2013
2,889
2,696
Finland
Oooooh I just found my perfect summer peach - L'Oreal Sexybalm in 103 As If I. It's a chubby, retractable pen and really moisturizing. Forget Shy Girl!