Urban Decay is fabulous. Soot is a really inky black, and I have a lot of other colors... application is easy too!
I find it extreeeemely hard not to smudge when you use liquid liners on asian singlelid eyes. As soon as you open your eyes after applying the liner, it'd smudge. I think I'm just gonna stick to crayon liners... =(
I use the L'oreal Intense. It's a brush so it may take awhile to get used to first but I love it. It doesn't smudge and stays on all day no matter what.