Batgnolles Horizontal or Montrogueil???

[heart_bags]

BH. I don't think the Monty looks modern at all, it's just a newer model.
The BH is a classic and the shape doesn't go out of date.
The shape of the Monty is a bit ball-like when it's empty and it sags big time when it's full. My grandma nearly bought one but didn't like it anymore once she put in all of her stuff in the shop. She got a Speedy B in the end.

You also need to keep in mind that the gold plaque will get very scratched and that the colour will probably rub off rather soon.

 

[irishjj]

Monty! I love mine, it fits so much! I think the BH looks a bit dated. The Monty has those cute pleats and the zip top which is a must have for me anyway. It doesn't sag as much as the Speedy and its only half full as I don't carry alot. Try both on if you get the chance. Good luck!

 

[jpg0150]

Bh

 

[abbie001]

Bh

 

[lasvegasann]

Bh

 

[bluetooth101]

Another vote for BH!

 

[gottabagit]

Monty

 

[dcooney4]

BH ,Monty's strap is just not long enough to wear with a thick coat for me.

 

[siworae]

This thread is nearly a year old... I'm going to assume the OP already made a decision.

 

[aznprncess]

I have the Monty PM but looking back would have prob been happier with a BH. Get the BH!!

 

[AnaVeronika]

i do not like the look od the bh. it looks a little dated for me. so, monty!

 

[Anastasia1991]

The BH is comfy and practical. However, I don't think it's a stylish bag..

 

[thanks sixx]

Monty....for the zipper.

 

[bubu123]

BH! I use my BH everytime I travel! It fits everything even my iPad or laptop.

 

[smileglu]

Monty! the zipper is a HUGE +