While I shop for many of my clothes at american eagle, I had never bought shoes there until last week. I bought a pair of their polka dot ballet flats and really put them through their paces... wore them for a flight, walked half a mile in them, then took them to a beach community. I loved them so much I went back for two more pairs! They are on clearance for $14 right now- and set to get new styles soon.
note: I like really lightweight, thin shoes that feel like you aren't wearing anything at all. If you're looking for something sturdy, these arent a good bet.