I have both the City and the Purse and I like them both equally. However, they really are two different bags. If you're looking for a satchel I suggest the City. If you want a true shoulder bag I suggest the Purse. IMO the Purse is the most feminine style of all the motorcycle bags. That is why I decided to get one in pale rose. Either bag is a winner. I think you should get a Purse since you already have a City. You won't be disappointed.