Ladies, I'm a newb whose about to quit eBay all together. This is crazy. I'm in love with the Paige, but there is a big difference between this eBay- and this - The shine! None of these eBay Koobas have the same shiny look as the Koobas I've seen from online retailers. Is there any chance Koobas from other seasons were more matte, or I am pushing my luck? And the sad thing is - I actually prefer matte leather. I'm so confused!!!