Michael Kors Aquamarine Selma or Hamilton...which to keep?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Scooch

Scooch

Proud Handbag Addict
O.G.
Dec 31, 2007
2,324
2,629
#1
Ok, me and hubby have decided to redo our bathroom so I was going through my collection to see what I can "let go" and this is my last dilemma, large Selma or Hamilton in aquamarine....which one would you keep?
ImageUploadedByPurseForum1436406032.111114.jpgImageUploadedByPurseForum1436406044.546860.jpg
 
#2
Do you have both bags in different colors already? I don't own a Hamilton as the n/s is too big and the e/w is too small for me. I do like the look of the Hamilton though but I guess I'm biased, bc to date my FAVORITE MK bag is my aquamarine large Selma. So that's my vote [emoji3] Good luck with your decision.
 
#3
HeatherL said:
Do you have both bags in different colors already? I don't own a Hamilton as the n/s is too big and the e/w is too small for me. I do like the look of the Hamilton though but I guess I'm biased, bc to date my FAVORITE MK bag is my aquamarine large Selma. So that's my vote [emoji3] Good luck with your decision.
Click to expand...


I do have the large Selma in black which I could never part with. This is my only Hamilton, I love the hardware but the Selma is an easier bag to carry. So confused [emoji53]
 
#4
I totally understand. When I became a MK addict I promised myself no duplicate bags (so many to choose from), but I love the Selma so much that I "needed" a neutral for when my aquamarine goes into hibernation. The Selma is just so practical but elegant. That is a very tough choice.
 
#5
I would keep the Hamilton. I like aquamarine on bags with more hardware. Plus, if you already have a Selma, I'd keep the Hamilton for more variety.
 
#9
Scooch said:
I do have the large Selma in black which I could never part with. This is my only Hamilton, I love the hardware but the Selma is an easier bag to carry. So confused [emoji53]
Click to expand...
The question for you is i) do you like a variety of handbag styles in your collection or ii) are you looking for what is most practical for your everyday lifestyle?

If your answer is i) then you should keep the Hamilton. You don't have another Hamilton in your collection.

If your answer is ii) then you should keep the Selma. You said it is an easier bag for you to carry.
 
#10
ubo22 said:
The question for you is i) do you like a variety of handbag styles in your collection or ii) are you looking for what is most practical for your everyday lifestyle?

If your answer is i) then you should keep the Hamilton. You don't have another Hamilton in your collection.

If your answer is ii) then you should keep the Selma. You said it is an easier bag for you to carry.
Click to expand...


Good point! I'm torn between the look of the Hamilton and the practical way Selma carries. Ugh!
 
#11
Scooch said:
Good point! I'm torn between the look of the Hamilton and the practical way Selma carries. Ugh!
Click to expand...
I have both, so problem solved! LOL! Honestly, if you already have a Selma and like the look of the Hamilton then I would keep the Hamilton and then focus future purchases back on the Selma. If you didn't already have a Selma then I would have said to keep the Selma. Now, if you really have problems carrying the Hamilton and it would sit in your closet because you would be reluctant to use it, then by all means get rid of it and keep the Selma! :smile1:
 
#12
Ok, I carried Hamilton yesterday and Selma today and Selma wins! Since they are the same gorgeous color Selma just carries better! Thanks for all the input!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top