I'm looking for a small everyday tote bag for when I only need to carry my wallet and cell phone. Right now I'm stuck between these two. I was going to get the Antigua in June but I ended up with the BV instead. I really like the blue of the Antigua and it's zipped top but I'm just not sure if it will work as a year round bag. The only thing I'm not so keen about is the open top on the Neverfull otherwise I can see myself using that everyday.