Amulette Cartier VS Tiffany Schlumberger Egg

Cartier Or Tiffany?

  • Amulette de Cartier

  • Tiffany egg in tiger's eye


Results are only viewable after voting.

Christofle

Member
Apr 21, 2011
4,229
3,080
Montreal
I'm currently deciding between these two options and your input would be appreciated. So far I'm leaning more towards the egg due to the variety of colours available.
 

Attachments

HADASSA

Member
Feb 22, 2012
3,286
2,816
I'm currently deciding between these two options and your input would be appreciated. So far I'm leaning more towards the egg due to the variety of colours available.
You are deciding between the AdeC bracelet and Schlumberger necklace, correct? Then my vote will be for the Tiffany :smile:
 

Christofle

Member
Apr 21, 2011
4,229
3,080
Montreal
You are deciding between the AdeC bracelet and Schlumberger necklace, correct? Then my vote will be for the Tiffany :smile:

Indeed, although for the Tiffany Egg, I'll only be purchasing the charm. My uncle is a jeweller so I might get a more interesting chain through him.
 

HADASSA

Member
Feb 22, 2012
3,286
2,816
You are deciding between the AdeC bracelet and Schlumberger necklace, correct? Then my vote will be for the Tiffany :smile:
Indeed, although for the Tiffany Egg, I'll only be purchasing the charm. My uncle is a jeweller so I might get a more interesting chain through him.
I do have the AdeC necklace (the one for $4450) and that is small. I think the egg charm will be a more substantial piece and yes, I am sure you will get a more interesting chain design elsewhere ;)
 
Nov 26, 2006
1,320
34
I'm also curious about the weight of Tiffany's Schlumberger egg. I am actually going tomorrow to possibly pick up a malachite egg.
 

sailorstripes

Member
Jan 20, 2011
540
156
NYC
Schlumberger egg all the way! The Amulette, while very pretty, is so very small and dainty, I was really surprised when I saw it in person!
 

karo

O.G.
Sep 5, 2006
18,872
30
Personally I prefer the amulette - simple, modern, beautiful! The egg is gorgeous too, but not my style. You should choose the one that is your style and the one you will wear.
 

dialv

VCA*Hermes*Yorkie
O.G.
Nov 24, 2006
1,687
449
Canada
How heavy would you say the egg is? I haven't been able to see them in my local Tiffany's.
I would say the weight is comparable to a quarter maybe a little heavier. I find them light but I can still tell it is on. I have all five and I am planning on putting them on a bracelet.
 

Christofle

Member
Apr 21, 2011
4,229
3,080
Montreal
Personally I prefer the amulette - simple, modern, beautiful! The egg is gorgeous too, but not my style. You should choose the one that is your style and the one you will wear.
I feel like I could wear the egg more often, since in many cases you can hide the necklace under a shirt, while the bracelet is harder to conceal. I guess I'll have to head to Toronto for some retail therapy.