Amethyst First OR 2007 Limited edition Magenta GSH City??

[HappyAngel]

Which one will you pick? I have a Amethyst FIRST and wondering if I should get rid of it & get the 2007 Limited edition Magenta city with giant silver hardware?? Which one should I pick? Should bright color be in a smaller bag like the FIRST? I think Magenta with silver hardware is gorgeous too!! Now, what should I do?? I hope you ladies can give me some insight!

Thank you in advance!

 

[ehc2010]

I would prefer the amethyst first. I think amethyst is a prettier, brighter color.

 

[Moonstarr]

I say Amethyst as well. Only because it's on my wish list. When the colour first came out I thought it was too bright for a bag (for me) and just got it in a MU. But suddenly I have changed my mind and an Amethyst bag is on my wish list.

BTW .. I don't think you need to stick to a smaller bag for a brighter colour. I love bright bags and usually choose medium size bags.

 

[Zombie Girl]

Both!!

 

[pianoblue]

Amethyst first, I love the color. it is so pretty.

 

[Shea]

Definitely Amethyst, I prefer the colour, it's more lively and brighter!

 

[bellabags23]

I agree Amethyst is gorgeous!!!!!

 

[Ghost55]

I love them both...but I seem to gravitate more to the deep magenta. Only a little more though

 

[HappyAngel]

Thanks, Everyone!!! It seems like the majority of you want me to keep my amethyst...lol

 

[Alice1979]

LE magenta. The color is more saturated imo.

 

[SkyBlueDay]

Can you keep both?

If not, it depends on what you like to carry in your bag: if you carry a lot, then keep the City.

If you carry next to nothing, then keep the First.

 

[BlueKat]

It really depends on what you are looking for in a bag. There is an important size difference between both bags. If it were me, I would by the Magenta GSH City got its size, and the color combination is nice IMO.

 

[HandbagAngel]

I vote for 07 LE Magenta SGH City. First, it is a City, the most popular size. Second, its color is rich and saturated. Third, it has 2007 leather.

 

[whitelamb]

in my opinion with regards to the color issue, amethyst wins LE magenta hands down. period. amethyst has lots of character and is multi-toned. but i find a first way too tiny.

 

[Selkie]

my vote goes to the amethyst