alma amarante MM is really to die for, i own one and it was my hg bag, so i'm also biased
BUT i also want Artsy empriente, so i would suggest to try this bag first, as you already own alma in pomme.. i bet you will have a different experience with the new all leather bag, plus it is a shoulder bag too.
What about chanel flap, get the classic black which will be chic with all the outfits..
I got vintage xl and i'm so happy with her.. no regrets at all.. good luck