I vote for tutti.
Because like others said, finding an AS with characters you like is sort of a crapshoot. T-T Also, there's more empty white space to get dirty.
But my biggest reason is because I am a stickler for placement, and I fell in absolute LOVE with a section of the tutti print [it doesn't hurt that I enjoy the rest of the print too..minus the baby butt, hehe] and since the print is so big, it's like, BOOM! favorite part of the print large & in charge right on front of my bag!