Wow, let me first say both of those bags have beautiful leather and you really can't go wrong with either. But, I guess I'll be another one of the minority votes for the Step. I actually don't have either bag, but I plan on going to look at both this month and personally I like being able to wear my bag both on the shoulder and hand-held. Since you say the step fits better with the longer strap, then obviously you like to carry yours on your shoulder too? If so, go for the step. It may be more structured, but I like that in this look.