I bought the black leather Carly last week and got a really good deal from Macy's sale. I decided that I should go back for the black Signature Carly because I thought it looked a little bit more dressy than the blk-leather Carly. I also posted a question on this forum about the two purses to get opinions. Thank you ladies for your input! Now I need your help again . I got such a good deal on both of these purses, I wonder if I should keep both I got 20% off for the sale and then another 15% off for opening a Macy's card. These purses will be #3 and #4 in my Coach collection. 1st purse was a large white Soho flap with brown trim. My 2nd Coach was a large brown leather hobo. I think I am going a little "Coach NUTTY"! I've looked at other ladies purse collections posted on this site and noticed some ladies have the same bag in different colors. Any thoughts?