17P vs 17C black caviar boys

[calflu]

Hey ladies!

I wonder what's your view about 17P vs 17C black caviar boys?

I feel 17C is more suede feeling and more sturdy but 17P is softer and has a sheen to it

17P feels more like caviar minis chanel used to release (like my 14S black caviar)!

 

[calflu]

Here is 17P black caviar boy in light gold hw!
I prefer this over ruthenium

 

[lindamirella]

I love the ruthenium! 17P

 

[Passau]

Love the look of the17P!

 

[Natz15]

Here's a photo of my black caviar 17c for comparison... haven't seen or felt the 17p in person so I can't speak to the difference in feel but definitely the 17c is not as shiny. It's very interesting how different all 3 of these look in my opinion.

 

[revangelina]

View attachment 3574409

I love the ruthenium! 17P

I'm getting confused with the term Ruthenium HW. Is this an Aged Ruthenium HW? Or an Aged Silver HW. Cause the Ruthenium HW I know is that Black one in the So Black. Hope somebody can clear up my confusion .

 

[chlamy]

Here is 17P black caviar boy in light gold hw!
I prefer this over ruthenium View attachment 3574387

View attachment 3574409

I love the ruthenium! 17P

So the (shiny) black caviar boys 17P are available in both ruthenium and LGHW??

 

[alamaisontt]

So the (shiny) black caviar boys 17P are available in both ruthenium and LGHW??

Here is ruthenium for comparison

 

[lindamirella]

So the (shiny) black caviar boys 17P are available in both ruthenium and LGHW??

Yes !

 

[Vienna]

View attachment 3574409

I love the ruthenium! 17P

This caviar looks shinier than mine from last year. Although I think mine is the matte caviar even though I still see some shine to it.

 

[Roku]

Hey ladies!

I wonder what's your view about 17P vs 17C black caviar boys?

I feel 17C is more suede feeling and more sturdy but 17P is softer and has a sheen to it

17P feels more like caviar minis chanel used to release (like my 14S black caviar)!

Personally I love 17C better
You are right, the 17P Caviar Boys use the same caviar leather as the 17C classic caviar flaps.
The nodes are much smaller and tighter, giving it a sheen (I like to call it Masago, because they are the size of masago, not caviar! haha )

I prefer the 17C. I see the draw of 17P though.
I think the 17C version looks better with muted HW, and the 17P kind looks better with shiny.

 

[kulasa87]

Agreed 100% Love my 17C boy!

 

[cutiecue]

ok ladies, i need your thoughts too. I have purchased last Nov 2016 a chanel boy black caviar in aged ghw with the military green interior. Last week, my SA showed me their new arrivals and the boy black caviar in light gold hardware is one of them... Now I'm confused. Should I stick to the aged gold hardware or to this newer version. Adding to my confusion is that the new release has black interior and made in France. HELP!!!

 

[MsLVinDC]

Following

 

[calflu]

A comparison shot

I prefer shiny light gold hardware on 17P

17C caviar is matte and a bit suede feeling

I wonder if other 17P caviar boys in blue and red are similar to the black one?