Hi guys! I have both bags and thought to post some pictures to see the differences in both. I'm not so good in describing the leather, but I'll try my best! here's the picture of the 05 Choco. I bought her preloved. The leather is very soft and slouchy. The handles have darkened and softened. But you can see the color is still a rich even brown. Only one of the edge has a scuff, the rest perfect. The leather is SUPER thin and smooth. Has a waxy feel because of the smoothness and quite resistant to scratches n scuff! Amazing 05 leather.