04 Lilac = 08 Pale Magenta?

twiggers

O.G.
May 7, 2006
33,070
29
Hmmmmm....they do look kind of close! Man oh man....everytime I see that '08 magenta I want it LOL
 

ilikepenguins

Finally a PhD!
O.G.
Jun 29, 2006
3,929
3
Boston
oooo good thinking! I can't wait to see tPFer IRL pics, but if it does really look like '04 lilac, that would be awesome! I would really love a nice, more muted pink!
 

twiggers

O.G.
May 7, 2006
33,070
29
Yeah I want more IRL pics to decide. But if that is the case then I may wait until the end of the season and try to score one on ebay since I think I have enough pink ('05 magenta, '05 BG, and '08 petal pink) and couldn't justify another pink one to the hubby LOL
 

Gonatcha

O.G.
Apr 16, 2006
798
2
34
Europe
Nah, the o4 is purple, the 08 is pink - based on all photos I've seen of these colors I don't think they look close at all :nogood:
 

amiekbs8

O.G.
Mar 28, 2007
3,533
0
NYC
I think 08 Magenta looks like the lovechild of 04Lilac and 07Magenta. Either way, I'm in love with it and I want Magenta!
 

BohoChic

O.G.
Jul 27, 2007
273
41
I think 08 Magenta looks like the lovechild of 04Lilac and 07Magenta. Either way, I'm in love with it and I want Magenta!
We are so on the same page! I have all of the pictures of Magenta on my computer desktop like some sort of teenage boy--only I'm lusting over handbag porn!

:love::heart:

I need that love child now!
 

Murphy66

Member
May 21, 2007
383
1
Here's a pic of my amazingly gorgeous old Lilac 04 and I think the color is captured pretty well here. I haven't seen the pale magenta but I'd really think it would be more pink than this. And then rose 04 next to it. I doubt these are really helping anyone but at least they're pretty! I do think the new one will be smack in the middle of these two.

 

amiekbs8

O.G.
Mar 28, 2007
3,533
0
NYC
Here's a pic of my amazingly gorgeous old Lilac 04 and I think the color is captured pretty well here. I haven't seen the pale magenta but I'd really think it would be more pink than this. And then rose 04 next to it. I doubt these are really helping anyone but at least they're pretty! I do think the new one will be smack in the middle of these two.

hubba hubba! *whistles like a construction worker at a leggy lady* Ok, I really think that my bf being "too tired" is making me lust after bags in a very weird way! lol Oh well, better than ice cream!
 

BohoChic

O.G.
Jul 27, 2007
273
41
Quote:
"Ohhh mama, I think I'm gonna have to dance . . . "

--What I say in my best Elvis voice, every single time I see a picture of the 08' Magenta!!!!

LOL!!! (but seriously, I'm not kidding).