yay or nay? pic attached

[mammab]

not sure . . .

 

[REREsaurus]

Eh... it's cute.

I like the perfo, but I don't like the covered hardware stuff. Not for me.

 

[aki_sato]

Errr...I will say nay

The bag looks over the top with the covered HW and all the trimming...

Too much IMO ----> from a girl who loves the classic regular hardware bags

 

[bags4fun]

I think it is yummy, and different!

 

[labelfiend]

Not feeling it. With everything on the bag being monochromatic, it is like that zipper is screaming at me.

 

[oogiewoogie]

Eh... it's cute.

I like the perfo, but I don't like the covered hardware stuff. Not for me.

ditto

 

[imonpurseblog]

I love the perf and am undecided about the GH. I would love to see it with the RH.

 

[mammab]

if only the zipper wasn't so dang bright silver....that's what getting me....

anyone else?

 

[tanmon]

i'd say it would be yay if it was EITHER the perf OR the covered hardware.

but both together looks too severe --- especially on a black bag.

 

[willowsmom]

Another one with the "perfo is ok, but not so crazy about the ch" crowd.

 

[hayley]

not loving it ...

 

[cbarrus]

I have to say, I saw a perforated bag with covered hardware today at Bob Ellis, and I did not like it - sorry. It's not that it's not pretty, really, but it's too much going on, and I prefer the classic look (regular hardware). I like a bag that if you do not wear it for a while, it will still look in style when you do. These bags are probably just too trendy looking for me.

 

[CiaoManhattan]

Love the perforated leather... but not the covered hardware... weren't people having issues with it peeling off as well?

So I'd say NAY

 

[whipsmart]

hmm NAY.

 

[HandbagAngel]

I saw the CGH Black both City and Work IRL, and I have to say it's not my style at all. Overall it looks weird to me. Probably just likes other girls said earlier, there are too much going on, and Bal lost its beauty with this design IMHO.