I would say if you don't love your new items, then probably returning them is best. I almost bought that key pouch. I think it's SOOO cute, but then I didn't think I would use it since it doesn't hold cards very easily. I absolutely LOVE that wallet, and I also almost bought the teal accordion zip until I found out there was a matching Bridgit and bought that instead. I would really rather have a whole bag than spend $300 on a wallet, so I couldn't bring myself to do it. I usually just wait and find my wallets at the outlets, or when places like Lord and Taylor blow them out...or Maxx gets them, etc. I think you will probably be happier with the ergo pleated since it's a bag rather than two items you don't seem to be overly happy with. The pleated bags are SO hot!! Good luck on your decision, and keep us posted!!