I have the pomme vernis 4-key holder, used daily for a year, and it's still just as gorgeous as the day I bought it. I don't think you can go wrong with pomme, or even Amarante (although I love the Pomme moor).
I think Vernis holds up very well as long as it's in a darker color. I love mine. I've been using my new mono cles lately because I love having a place to put my YMCA and VIC cards, but I'm considering a pomme cles too because I miss the color so much. It's gorgeous, especially in sunlight.