Should I get this scarf?

I agree with abitzberger... the first scarf is pretty and will contrast rather nicely with the chocolate Carly but it is too long. Your second scarf choice will look just as nice on your Carly.
 
Yeah, the second one has a richer color to it & is shorter. Check out my pic below, I have a ponytail scarf tied to the bag in the middle & i believe it's the same size as the second scarf you posted. it's a great way to add spunk to a bag :smile: good luck bidding & congrats!!!