Help!! need your input/opinion

[thegraceful1]

I need help deciding on The Sarpei Quilted Flap (pictured from Jill's thread)

http://forum.purseblog.com/chanel/woof-another-sharpei-in-da-house-lol-176136.html

Or the new Envelope Flap (pictured from ladydeluxe's thread)

http://forum.purseblog.com/chanel/je-presente-my-new-envelope-flap-189262.html

I need a big BLACK flap bag (already have a jumbo flap)

Thank you!!

 

[jfhave]

Are they around the same price?

 

[thegraceful1]

Are they around the same price?

I dont know, but it does not matter (pricewise), what do you think looks best?, why??

 

[shopgirl bb]

Definitley the Envelope. I am also thinking of getting one. It's kinda like a soft jumbo flap which is light to carry.

 

[chanelspell]

The sharpey any sharpey. It's more feminine !Sorry I don't like the envelope at all.Did you try any of them all,because sometimes we don't like something until we see it on us!

 

[laksalala]

i like both but i like the sharpey a bit more

 

[Miss Sooky]

I prefer the envelope but it is a close run thing and I actually love them both - you can't go wrong!

 

[Clandy]

These are both beautiful but very different bags. I love the sharpei but have concluded I would never buy it because it appears to be so fragile. I have a couple of lambskin bags but the leather on those bags is glazed so it is tougher than the very soft leather of the sharpei. I vote for the envelope as a more practical all around bag.

 

[sharbear508]

I voted for the sharpei...it's soooo pretty! And the leather just looks so smushy...

 

[essential]

i like the envelope more

 

[ldldb]

i like both of these bags but i am leaning more toward the sharpei. i can't resist anything that has ruching or pleating. plus i think the envelope resembles your jumbo flap more than the sharpei. Norma, i am still pining away for that dark silver sharpei that Jill posted from the hawaii store so i think you know where my vote went!!

 

[gucci fan]

I like the sharpei. Looks so edgy and fun.

 

[thegraceful1]

OKAY...this poll is closed!!!
Got the last one avail. Sharpei Quilted Flap thanks to Jill's SA (Jillian Chanel/Palm Beach Gardens) so I should get it next week

 

[czo28]

I voted for the sharpey flap. It is gorgeous.

 

[chanelspell]

OKAY...this poll is closed!!!
Got the last one avail. Sharpei Quilted Flap thanks to Jill's SA (Jillian Chanel/Palm Beach Gardens) so I should get it next week

Congrats !Can't wait for pics when you receive it!