Hi DD101, what made you decide on the distressed caviar?
I like the distressed look, plus I knew I could really USE this bag, and not worry, no need to be careful with it and baby it. I really liked the metallic black too, but I felt it somehow had a bit of a dressy look, and I am more on the casual side. I'm sure there are pf'ers that use the metallic black as a casual bag, but for me it seemed dressy. It really all depends on what you prefer, do you like the leather to have a bit of a sheen to it? Or do you prefer the distressed leather?
Just so you know, I use me Le Marias (gold/black) flap as an everyday bag. Some might feel this bag is more dressy because of the gold (this gold lends itself to silver too, it's a matt distressed metallic), but it's distressed, so to me this is casual. But it depends on YOU and what YOU like. Doesn't matter how we would carry a bag, think of your life style and what usually works best for you.
Can't wait to see which you choose, both are really beautiful
I have to add that the above poster is correct, the distressed black caviar is more of a grey black, not a deep dark solid midnight black. I have a jumbo flap in black caviar with the old chain, so that black caviar is a bit shiny, so the distressed one was a different look for me.