Okay, I am between the Carly and the Legacy... decisions decisions...
LOL! kphillips you got a lot of stuff in that bag!!! I think I may like all of the hardware on the Legacy, but the Carly can go both casual and dressy... oh man????
And even with all that stuff in there it's not very heavy. You can always do like I and get a Legacy shoulder in leather and a choc carly!! There, problem solved!!
I think everyone has given you great choices! YOu can't go wrong with any of them. Any chance you can go to a boutique and try them all on? Thats probably the best way to narrow it down. What are your favorite features in a bag? light weight? pockets/zippers on outside? long drop length? Whats important to you?
Carly carly carly! She is amazingly beautiful, holds alot, and is super comfortable! The chocolate brown Carly, imho, is the epitomy of a perfect fall bag.