I like metal bracelets and big faces, so I vote the second one of the two.
Also, I forgot which watches you already tried on... If you like this style, did you try on the Cartier Tank Solo? The Tank is an iconic watch, it's low profile compared to other luxury brands, and the Solo comes in a metal bracelet. Tanks are also not expensive, and you get a lot of "brand image" bang for the buck. Here is a link:
CRW5200014 - Tank Solo watch - Large model, quartz movement, steel - Cartier
Here is the link to all Tanks with leather or metal bracelets:
Tank (cartier.com)
I realize it's ultimately what you like. Given you also like VCA and other luxury brands, for me... I just think a nice watch is part of the whole jewelry look. I know you say you are not flashy, but yet you buy VCA, so I would dare say labels matter (they do to me).
Jewelry and watches are fashion, and everyone has a look. For me, part of my "look" is super casual dress, but fine jewelry and a luxury watch (e.g. Rolex Daytona for me). I would suggest to really think about your look to be sure you don't regret your purchase and then wished you had purchased something else. My gut says if you are thinking your Swatch is not working with your current look, the Longines may not either after a short period.
Just my two cents of course to help you look at other views. Good luck!
Hello, I think we hold the different opinions since day 1. remember the lotus earrings post? I like Lotus earrings but you don't, and this is fine. Couples don't hold the same opinions, let alone people that we meet on the forum.
To me, brands are not as important as the designs. First I need to like the design and then I have emotional connection to the brand then I become a loyal customer. To me Swatch group is important because of 2 real life stories.
In my secondary school year, my teacher gifted me and my 2 best friends a Swatch watch, because after teaching us for 2 years, it was time for her to retire so my friends and I bought her a gift but she refused to receive unless we accepted the watch as a return. The message she sent out is like 'The value of a watch does not lie within a watch but what a watch represents---TIME.' She lives in an affluent area of the city so her message was very convincing.
And fast forward 2 decades or so, I was in the low point of my life and was preparing for my job interview, guess what, I needed an affordable and presentable watch for my interview. I turned to Swatch watch because it was very robust and presentable as they offer stainless steel version. Guess what? No, I did not get the job but it turned out to be a blessing to me cos in the mist of Covid, there was a huge laid-off from that company that did not hire me. Instead of working for them, I got a secure job and live happily now.
So SWATCH group inspired me once and saved me once hence the emotional connection to this brand or the group. If I don't get a Longines, I might get a Breguet or Omega which are all from Swatch. But if I get a Breguet, I need to skip Lotus earrings or 20 motif necklace for a long while.
So purchasing a Longines allows me to get items from VCA more often.
Do we really need to purchase all items from high-end brand just to match VCA? If so, many VCA lovers should wear Dior or Chanel all the time--- I mean all the time, not just once a week or twice and not limited to one or 2 suits.
To me, VCA is not flashy, to me, it is the pattern from Alhambra palace from Granada Spain. I went there and I know, the motifs were in blue though from the palace. And what is more, the first time I travelled to Paris, I found the lady-bugs in a hidden oriental garden on my way to the Eiffel tower. And so Lucky spring collection means something to me. Their designs speak to me again and again and I can relate hence I love the brand so much. VCA is my life experience in a way. Not the representation of my status nor my identity.
I change my Swatch because it is in stainless steel color and I want the watch in gold tone with leather strap to match with my gold VCA.