A mini dilemma...

[Elaine L.]

Help! Which to keep - rectangle black with SHW or square black pearl crush? They're too similar to keep both imo...what do you guys think?

 

[minnnea]

The rectangle. I would freak out in the fear of the ”pearl” getting loose or something. Though not sure if that is a real concern.

 

[Elaine L.]

The rectangle. I would freak out in the fear of the ”pearl” getting loose or something. Though not sure if that is a real concern.

Hmmmm that's a valid point though. I never even thought about that, although it does seem pretty sturdy but you'd just never know!

 

[XCCX]

Definitely the rectangle!

 

[BrownBuggy]

I would choose the rectangular mini, but you choose which makes you more happier

 

[Elaine L.]

Yeah - I'm just torn and would love to keep both lol

 

[sydsunshine]

I would keep both and not sell any. They are both beautiful and hard to get bags.

 

[ItsPurseonal]

If I remember correctly, the strap length is pretty different on the two? I would pick the one that works best for you on the shoulder and crossbody

 

[Sundaymacaron]

I’m not a fan of the dangling chain on the pearl crush, tbh i think it would date the bag in the long run. i’d personally rather tie the chain inside the bag of the mini rectangle to adjust the length. But whatever makes your heart sing is what matters

 

[Elaine L.]

I would keep both and not sell any. They are both beautiful and hard to get bags.

I might have to do this since I cannot decide haha

 

[Elaine L.]

If I remember correctly, the strap length is pretty different on the two? I would pick the one that works best for you on the shoulder and crossbody

Yes it's pretty different. The pearl crush has a longer and thinner strap...but is adjustable. The mini has the regular strap that is long enough for cross body. I love the antique hw on the pearl crush though.

 

[Elaine L.]

I’m not a fan of the dangling chain on the pearl crush, tbh i think it would date the bag in the long run. i’d personally rather tie the chain inside the bag of the mini rectangle to adjust the length. But whatever makes your heart sing is what matters

I was playing around with the strap and yeah, it does get pretty annoying when you shorten it and it leaves so much hanging chain. I guess I can tuck it inside the bag or something...

 

[Egel]

If you love them both, you can always get the rectangle later. The pearl crush it will be harder to replace.

Does hw matters? If you are a gold gal, get the pearl. If silver is more your style, get the rectangle.

I am more prone to skippers remorse than buyers regret so I would always keep the one that is harder to come by in the future.

 

[Elaine L.]

If you love them both, you can always get the rectangle later. The pearl crush it will be harder to replace.

Does hw matters? If you are a gold gal, get the pearl. If silver is more your style, get the rectangle.

I am more prone to skippers remorse than buyers regret so I would always keep the one that is harder to come by in the future.

You're absolutely right. The pearl was absolutely an adventure to find!!!

 

[Egel]

You're absolutely right. The pearl was absolutely an adventure to find!!!

The rectangle mini is also not easy to come by, but at least that one will come back.

And if you already put so much effort into getting the pearl, I am even more voting for the pearl. Or both if money isn't an obstacle.