Is noir too similar to bleu nuit?

[ivy1026]

Hi ladies/gents, I currently have a noir b25 on my wish list as I think it is a classic to have in my collection. However, I already have a bleu nuit b30 in ghw. Do you think they are too similar? TIA

 

[chicinthecity777]

Yes, too similar.

 

[coloradolvr]

Yes.

 

[momoc]

I think the color will be similar, but you said B30 in one and B25 in the other. So I think the size difference makes them different and is a reason for having both (assuming you find uses for both sizes).

 

[Txoceangirl]

I think different due to size and color. I have a BN Kelly 28 and noir Birkin 30, both PHW. I use for totally different wardrobe color ways more so than the bag style. I can't do a pic right now but can later today. Let me know if you think that will help.

 

[bagalogist]

I also have a blue nuit K28 GHW and a black B30 GHW, I wanted to have both blue nuit and black so it doesn't matter what others think. If you are hankering for black, get it.

 

[CMilly]

I wear a lot of black and a lot of navy. I don’t find them similar personally but I prefer neutrals. I have attached a photo of both in Clemence. Both get a lot of use and I have a blue nuit k with phw on my wish list (have a black one). My black H bags have ghw and my blue nuit have palladium.

 

[tensgrl]

I have a birkin 30 in both blue nuit PHW and also a birkin 30 black PHW. I use them with totally different outfits and never considered not having both. That said, I really only have neutral bags in my collection and wear mostly neutral outfits.

 

[Classy Collector]

Since they are different sizes I would say no. If they’re also different hardware then certainly no.

 

[MDNYC]

Not similar at all. I have both B30 blue nuit rose gold and B25 Black GHW. I love them both. I use mine all the time.

 

[ivy1026]

I think the color will be similar, but you said B30 in one and B25 in the other. So I think the size difference makes them different and is a reason for having both (assuming you find uses for both sizes).

thanks. I am thinking b30 is more when I am going out with my daughter since I have to put her stuff in there too and the b25 for just me when I am going out by myself

 

[ivy1026]

I think different due to size and color. I have a BN Kelly 28 and noir Birkin 30, both PHW. I use for totally different wardrobe color ways more so than the bag style. I can't do a pic right now but can later today. Let me know if you think that will help.

Bleu nuit can definitely look more blue under different lighting. A pic would help if you don’t mind and TIA

 

[ivy1026]

I also have a blue nuit K28 GHW and a black B30 GHW, I wanted to have both blue nuit and black so it doesn't matter what others think. If you are hankering for black, get it.

both are nice neutral and hard to just to pick one for sure

 

[ivy1026]

I wear a lot of black and a lot of navy. I don’t find them similar personally but I prefer neutrals. I have attached a photo of both in Clemence. Both get a lot of use and I have a blue nuit k with phw on my wish list (have a black one). My black H bags have ghw and my blue nuit have palladium.

Different hardware will definitely make a difference

 

[ivy1026]

I have a birkin 30 in both blue nuit PHW and also a birkin 30 black PHW. I use them with totally different outfits and never considered not having both. That said, I really only have neutral bags in my collection and wear mostly neutral outfits.

that’s perfect and we can never go wrong with these two neutrals