Aquazzura

I take a 38.5 in their flats, and a 38.5 or 39 in their heels. I would say my feet are on the narrow side. I wear a 38.5-39 in Jimmy Choo; a 38-39 in CL; 39-39.5 in MB; and 38.5-39 in Valentino (38.5 in the kitten heels and pumps; 39 in their flats). So based on what you've said I would say to go for the 38.5.

Hope this helps!

Thanks! I just saw these replies. I appreciate it .I ended up going with the 38.5