Which Diamond Ring Should I Choose ?

[Kiribell]

Hello lovely Purse Forum members,
I have been given the choice of the following two round brilliant diamond engagement rings. For complicated reasons they are my only two choices. Which do you think has the better cut and is bigger necessarily better ? Which would you choose and why? The stats are as follows :

Ring # 1
Weight : 3.240 carats
Color Grade: E
Clarity Grade: VS1

Cut Proportions :
Total Depth Percentage: 59.7%
Table Size Percentage: 60%
Crown Height Percentage: 13.5%
Crown Angle: 33.8
Pavilion Depth Percentage: 43.4%
Pavilion Angle: 41.0
Symmetry: Excellent
Cut Measurements: 9.64 x 9.66 x 5.76 mm

Ring # 2
Weight: 3.510 carats
Color Grade: E
Clarity Grade: VS 1

Cut Proportions:
Total Depth Percentage: 60.1%
Table Size Percentage: 60%
Crown Height Percentage: 13.4%
Crown Angle: 33.8
Pavilion Depth Percentage: 43.6%
Pavilion Angle: 41.1
Symmetry: Excellent
Cut Measurements: 9.86 x 9.89 x 5.94

TIA for your help and advice.

 

[Miraku]

They are SO similar. I'd say they're even the same. Your eye (and probably even an experienced jeweller) will not be able to tell. All of your percentage differences are <0.5%.

 

[FunBagz]

Head over to the RockyTalk forum on PriceScope for good diamond advice.

 

[Kiribell]

Head over to the RockyTalk forum on PriceScope for good diamond advice.

Thank you so much for your help.