Poll! Help Me Pick a Bag Charm for Edie!

[katev]

A friend of mine recently got her first Coach bag. It is her dream bag, a Turnlock Edie 36855 DK NAV navy pebbled leather shoulder bag with dark gunmetal hardware.

I was recently shopping at the Nordstrom Rack sales on Coach fobs and I decided to pick up a nice fob or bag charm so that she can decorate her new Edie. But I found 2 great fobs and couldn't decide between them so I bought them both! But right now I am only planning to give one fob to her, the money isn't an issue, but I don't want her bag to look junky!

The fobs I bought as possible decorations for the Navy Turnlock Edie are:
Exotic Studded Clover 65122 BK GRS
Navy and Dark Gunmetal Long Tassel 65834 BK NAV

Please take a look at the pictures below and use the poll above to let me know which charm you think will best compliment my friend's dream bag, thanks!

 

[gr8onteej]

Long tassel.

 

[Hobbsy]

I'm on my phone and don't see the poll....but I vote tassel.

 

[alansgail]

The tassel is lovely but imo the expected choice. I prefer the unexpectedness of the clover though don't think you can go wrong with either choice.

 

[Lucylu29]

Even though I think the tassel is a great match for this bag I like the clover because I think it will stand out more and I love blue and green together.

This is a hard choice!

 

[elvisfan4life]

I vote both tbh

 

[katev]

Long tassel.

I'm on my phone and don't see the poll....but I vote tassel.

Thanks, I don't know how she feels about bag charms, but she has made nice comments about some of my fobs in the past. I think the tassel is an understated and classic choice, so she might like it a lot.

 

[katev]

The tassel is lovely but imo the expected choice. I prefer the unexpectedness of the clover though don't think you can go wrong with either choice.

Even though I think the tassel is a great match for this bag I like the clover because I think it will stand out more and I love blue and green together. This is a hard choice!

Thanks, I like the pop of color that the clover offers. The bag is dark and so is the hardware and the lining is black, so a little splash of green might give it just the right note. I just don't know how she feels about wearing bag charms that are fun and a bit whimsical.

 

[katev]

I vote both tbh

I like both of them too, maybe I should show them both to her and let her pick! That's what I did after buying 3 briefcases for my husband's birthday!

 

[MiaBorsa]

Either one, but be sure you let her know that if she doesn't care for the look, you won't be upset. Bag charms are a personal choice and since this is her dream bag, she may not want to add a charm.

 

[katev]

Either one, but be sure you let her know that if she doesn't care for the look, you won't be upset. Bag charms are a personal choice and since this is her dream bag, she may not want to add a charm.

Very true, I will make that clear, thanks!

 

[elvisfan4life]

I like both of them too, maybe I should show them both to her and let her pick! That's what I did after buying 3 briefcases for my husband's birthday!

I think it would be fab for her to have both to have choice as both go so.well

 

[jan1124]

Clover! More unique - and it will remind her how lucky[emoji256] she was to get her dream bag[emoji4]

 

[alansgail]

If you did present her with both charms (great idea btw) then she could always use the clover as a keyring and the tassel on her bag if she prefers more understated charms. They both would match her dream bag beautifully.

 

[yellowbernie]

I vote tassel