It depends what colors do you mosty wear with your jeans. I was thinking of getting the beige myself, and I went to look at it in person today. I thought that this shade will easyly match with anything, but once I have tried it on I realized that it will not be easy to match with a lot of things I wear. Although beautiful, I felt that the shiny beige caviar with very shiny light gold hardware is a bit too excessive for my liking. I also noticed some tracis of dirt on he bottom corners of the beige caviar already. Overall, I advice you if you can easily incorporate beige into your wardrobe and the shiny caviar with very shiny hardware do not bother you, then go for the beige over black as the shade of beige is beautiful. I personally did not get it for myslef.