I have tried both bags and I love both. At the end I bought Cluny bb and twice emp Rb color. St germain looks so pretty but I don't really like the clasp closure. Also I am worried that chain will not be comfortable once I load up my stuff. Lockme 2 bb- I tried yesterday at store. I think it is functional and understated. I am not sure how it wears in the long run since the leather is soft. They only had black which I think it is a little boring so I bought twice RB color. But I kept thinking if I should exchange. Difficult decision.........