Should I keep it or return it?

Yoish

Member
May 20, 2013
145
9
Hi ladies, I purchased this box calf 28 Kelly in orange. I didn't realise that deep scratch until I received the bag. The scratch was located in the front near the bottom. It seem like caused by keys or diamond ring , the skin off too. Do you think that can be fixed by the spa. Should I keep it or return to the reseller. This is such rare color.
 

Attachments

  • 1394390875575.jpg
    1394390875575.jpg
    45.6 KB · Views: 2,447
  • 1394390892684.jpg
    1394390892684.jpg
    48.4 KB · Views: 2,452
  • 1394390906550.jpg
    1394390906550.jpg
    65.5 KB · Views: 2,463
  • 1394390922054.jpg
    1394390922054.jpg
    35.2 KB · Views: 2,459
  • 1394390937413.jpg
    1394390937413.jpg
    43.4 KB · Views: 2,447
  • 1394390952280.jpg
    1394390952280.jpg
    43.2 KB · Views: 2,447
  • 1394390972454.jpg
    1394390972454.jpg
    63.2 KB · Views: 2,447
  • 1394390995875.jpg
    1394390995875.jpg
    27.1 KB · Views: 2,433
This harsh scratch should have been revealed by the reseller and should not have been a surprise to you. Oh my. Not right. If the price was really good and you love her despite the scratch, then that is your business and right of course. I personally could not live with that scratch unless I had done it myself, and then I'd march straight to Docride or the boutique. Good luck.
 
This harsh scratch should have been revealed by the reseller and should not have been a surprise to you. Oh my. Not right. If the price was really good and you love her despite the scratch, then that is your business and right of course. I personally could not live with that scratch unless I had done it myself, and then I'd march straight to Docride or the boutique. Good luck.

The seller just mention the scratch is only minor hair line. However, it is not, I am very disappointed
 
Great bag, but for that money I would want it perfect, never mind a minor-turned-major scratch.

I think the H spa could minimise but not erase, I wouldn't do any DIY

Certainly worth asking for a 30% discount, if no go then return
 
The seller just mention the scratch is only minor hair line. However, it is not, I am very disappointed
I agree with sparklelisab. This shouldn't be a surprise. Did you see the picture of the scratch before hand? It doesn't look like a minor hairline scratch to me. Prices are dependant upon many factors like age, condition, color, rarity, etc (and how much you want it). To me it's about whether I know what I was getting and then deciding if it was a fair price. If you decide to keep it, I'd suggest discussing with the seller about discount because the spa will not be free--this all depends on whether or not the seller was being clear/honest with the description in the first place. G'luck!
 
I agree with sparklelisab. This shouldn't be a surprise. Did you see the picture of the scratch before hand? It doesn't look like a minor hairline scratch to me. Prices are dependant upon many factors like age, condition, color, rarity, etc (and how much you want it). To me it's about whether I know what I was getting and then deciding if it was a fair price. If you decide to keep it, I'd suggest discussing with the seller about discount because the spa will not be free--this all depends on whether or not the seller was being clear/honest with the description in the first place. G'luck!

The seller only took one picture on the scratch in flat angle. It is hard to see on that picture. I understand this is per owned condition, i cannot expect in prefect condition, but the seller Should describe clearly in such expensive item.
 
The seller only took one picture on the scratch in flat angle. It is hard to see on that picture. I understand this is per owned condition, i cannot expect in prefect condition, but the seller Should describe clearly in such expensive item.

It is a a beautiful bag, and although I am not a fussy person the scratch would bother me as it was not properly disclosed. I would expect to pay half the original price for that sort of flaw. The top layer of the leather is missing so it's not as if it would go unnoticed.