Help Me Decide FAST! Which leather looks better?

[hrhsunshine]

Hi Bal Pals,

I'm considering two bags and their leather is really making it tough for me to decide. My SA sent me these two shots. Which one looks like it has the better, yummier, more wrinkled/distressed leather? I absolutely LOVE wrinkles...big deep huge wrinkles. These are the two best she could find.

I made the photos huge so you can best see the texture in detail.

I have an idea which one I will pick, but wanted some input too. Trying to make a decision by tonight or tomorrow. Thanks ladies!

Bag #1 (no dot)

Bag #2 (green dot)

 

[bannYlein]

I think they look both great!
To me they have the same structure ,
but maybe the wrinkles on the second one are a tiny bit deeper

The first one seems to have a little mark on the right corner ,
there where the buckle is ...or maybe it's just the pic

 

[Yikkie]

Green dot!!

 

[oOChuChuOo]

2nd/Green dot! Is that Curry? The second one looks amazing!

 

[hrhsunshine]

I think they look both great!
To me they have the same structure ,
but maybe the wrinkles on the second one are a tiny bit deeper

The first one seems to have a little mark on the right corner ,
there where the buckle is ...or maybe it's just the pic

Green dot!!

2nd/Green dot! Is that Curry? The second one looks amazing!

Thanks Bal Pals!
Yes, it is Curry. Super pretty yellow. Hope it is awesome IRL!

Bann, I asked my SA to check on that mark you mentioned to see if it really is a mark or what.

I'm excited to hear more opinions as the day goes on. So excited. This will be my first super light bright colored Bal! Yikes! Can I handle it?

 

[oOChuChuOo]

Yes you can! Matches your name even!

Thanks Bal Pals!
Yes, it is Curry. Super pretty yellow. Hope it is awesome IRL!

Bann, I asked my SA to check on that mark you mentioned to see if it really is a mark or what.

I'm excited to hear more opinions as the day goes on. So excited. This will be my first super light bright colored Bal! Yikes! Can I handle it?

 

[outtacontrol]

I prefer the first bag. They leather seems more wrinkly and chewy to me.

 

[Livia1]

Uh, I get dizzy .. they're both gorgeous.
I'd take the second one though.
I realise the first one might look more wrinkly but I think the lighting, angle etc. "helps".
The second one, definitely

 

[rycechica1016]

theyre both nicely distressed but prefer pic 2 with green dot gl!

 

[HeartMyMJs]

They both look great! I would chose the first one.

 

[hrhsunshine]

Yes you can! Matches your name even!

I prefer the first bag. They leather seems more wrinkly and chewy to me.

Uh, I get dizzy .. they're both gorgeous.
I'd take the second one though.
I realise the first one might look more wrinkly but I think the lighting, angle etc. "helps".
The second one, definitely

theyre both nicely distressed but prefer pic 2 with green dot gl!

They both look great! I would chose the first one.

Thanks ladies. Looks like Miss Green Dot is winning. Will wait and see if we get some more votes

Yes, ChuChuOo, it does match my name so I MUST get one, right?

 

[Nanaz]

I like the second one. I saw this color yesterday at NM. It is very bright and happy color.

 

[Lara Madeleine]

Hi - I don't know the leather of your other Bal bags. Though the second one looks more distressed, I think the leather on the first looks better. Wrinkles are more even and leather seems thicker.

 

[BAGLADY-SHOEFLY]

Dot!

 

[maxxout]

Hi sweets
I Think the first one looks best. Maybe it's the lighting and the shadows but it looks more smushy and soft.