I don't think it was Pearl after all. It looks like the Dusty/Silver Spot one on Bonanza now.
I actually bought that exact bag last year from Bluefly. I was so excited to get it and then checked it over and saw those red pen marks on the side of the bag. Was super disappointed. I contacted BF to see if they would discount the bag any further but they wouldn't, so I ended up sending it back. It's a gorgeous bag IRL! Just didn't want to spend that kind of money on a bag that was supposedly new and wasn't.