Please Help Me Decide. Mustard vs Lemon

[wodlrla]

I have a yellow dilemma. When I saw F/W 2012 colors on Proenza Schouler site, I thought I would for sure get Mustard and not sure about Lemon. However, after seeing pics of Mustard and Lemon from Barneys, I'm not sure now. From Barneys.com, Mustard looks a bit washed out and Lemon looks pretty nice.

Has anyone seen both IRL? Which color would you choose for PS1 Medium?
Does Mustard look like the one from Barneys or PS site IRL?
Does Lemon have noticeable green undertone? Is it pretty much the same as Citron from S/S?

Thanks for your help ladies! So many pretty colors make the decision hard!!!

Mustard from Barneys:
http://www.barneys.com/Proenza-Schouler-PS1-Medium-Leather/00505017793346,default,pd.html
Lemon from Barneys:
http://www.barneys.com/Proenza-Schouler-PS1-Medium-Leather/00505017793407,default,pd.html

Mustard from Mytheresa:
http://www.mytheresa.com/us_en/ps1-...source=Affilate&utm_medium=INT&utm_campaign=2

Mustard from PS site:
http://www.proenzaschouler.com/cata...s1-medium-leather/category/129/?color=Mustard
Lemon from PS site:
http://www.proenzaschouler.com/cata.../ps1-medium-leather/category/129/?color=Lemon

 

[Mulberry_Love]

Mustard!
It's such a rich shade which you can wear all year round.

The lemon is more for this season. I think the neon aspect will be boring after a while

 

[Micole]

Mustard mustard mustard. MulberryLove described it perfectly: rich. And I think it will wear so much better over time. It's one of those colors I think will just improve with age. I'm not so sure about the lemon in that regard.

 

[BagLover21]

Another vote for mustard. I love the golden tone of it. Will be beautiful for years to come.

 

[LoveHandbags!]

Mustard wins out for me as I am more inclined to chose a leather that I am able to wear year round. I agree with my fellow PF'ers in that I believe this leather will age much better than the Lemon. Yay, what a fun decision though!!!!

 

[trigirl]

My vote goes to mustard too!

 

[wodlrla]

Thank you ladies for your opinions!
I took the plunge and ordered Mustard PS1 Medium!!!

Hope the color is as nice as the one in PS1 site pics and not washed out like Barneys IRL. Thanks again for your help and I will for sure do a reveal once I receive it!!!

 

[Micole]

Thank you ladies for your opinions!
I took the plunge and ordered Mustard PS1 Medium!!!

Hope the color is as nice as the one in PS1 site pics and not washed out like Barneys IRL. Thanks again for your help and I will for sure do a reveal once I receive it!!!

Yay! I'm so thrilled for you. I can't wait to see the pics. I hope you love it!