yax said:Yeah it's funny when people think they're pale but they really aren't. It's not like its some sort of competition or anything, it's really annoying to have such pale skin because no drug store colour is pale enough, and it's just unhelpful for people to give recommendations when they have a different version of pale : )
I don't know if this is a good indication of how pale your skin is or not, but I am unable to tan in the sun at all, which indicates that I have practically no melonin in my skin (the colour pigment).
Anyway, I think you're on to something with the concealers, sometimes the only products that are in the right colour are concealers, and I sometimes use them as foundations when I'm running out of Stila, as they are made lighter to go on the under eye area to brighten dark circles.
It's a big problem that so few foundations are made light enough for pale skin, but setting powders are a whole other problem. I've bought so many powders that look like they'll be pale enough but turn out to be orange. I don't know if you have Collection 2000 in the States but their palest shade is good for me, It's not a very nice formula though.
I've never seen Collection 2000, but I can always check online.
You're totally right about concealers. Also luminizers tend to be true white with just a hint of pink, blue or yellow. I prefer the blue ones as they offset the pinky tones that happen when I blush. They also give me that glowing look. The drawback is that they have no coverage. Fortunately, other than the big blue shadows under my eyes, I don't have much to conceal.
For powder, I've switched entirely to Make Up Forever HD translucent powder for setting. It's a true white, but meant to be translucent. It works beautifully on me. Plus it has a gorgeous silky texture.
I keep a small powder compact in my purse for touch-ups. I found it at Sephora; it's Sephora's "Tricks of the Trade" mineral touch-up powder in the lightest (translucent) shade. It's just off-white with a slight yellow tone to it. The tone is a bit like fresh butter. I went to link it here and of course they no longer carry it. Grr! Here are the reviews. Perhaps you can find it on MakeUpAlley or eBay.
http://reviews.sephora.com/8723/P244708/reviews.htm
I'm attaching a pic I took of a manicure I did - it shows the true color of my skin better than any other picture.