Can't decide between YSL Muse and MJ Hudson. Please, vote.

[redheadedbeauty]

I't such a hard decision for me , I like both bags but unfortunately getting both is not an option. Please, vote which bag do you like better and why: YSL Muse (probably in Oak or Orange) or MJ HUdson (probably in Chili or Chestnut).
TIA
1) YSL Muse
http://www.neimanmarcus.com/products/an/NMV8500_an.jpg

http://www.neimanmarcus.com/products/an/NMV8500_an.jpg

2) MJ HUdson

 

[RoseMary]

i prefer the muse.

 

[couturequeen]

The Muse. Have you seen the MJ in person? I'd try and go see both if you haven't. I don't think the leather is as good in the MJ.

 

[ada726]

MJ has always been one of my favorites, yet up against the Muse..that's a tough call. I say the Muse in oak, just based on style longevity..

 

[passerby]

Another vote for the Muse!

 

[butterfliie]

Muse for sure. Bigger bang for your buck!

 

[butterfliie]

Oh, to further complicate your decision, the Hudson in chestnut is on sale at saks.com:

Marc Jacobs - Hudson Striping Bag - Saks.com

 

[redheadedbeauty]

Oh, to further complicate your decision, the Hudson in chestnut is on sale at saks.com:

I've seen it and the sale price makes my decision even harder

 

[bagsforme]

I like the MJ. The two tone really makes it stand out.

 

[Beany]

Hudson, much prefer the straps

 

[redheadedbeauty]

I like the MJ. The two tone really makes it stand out.

I like the contrasting straps too but I'm concerned they (straps) might make the bag look dated in couple of years. What do you think?

 

[exotikittenx]

I really like the Hudson. Personally, I'm not a huge fan of the Muse. But I think the Muse is dressier... if you dress up a lot then go for that one.

 

[redheadedbeauty]

The Muse. Have you seen the MJ in person? I'd try and go see both if you haven't. I don't think the leather is as good in the MJ.

I've seen both bags IRL and actualy I like MJ's leather better than the Muse, it's softer, but it also maybe more prone to scratches........I don't know. So hard to make a decision - they both have their pros and cons for me (leather quality, shoulder strap length, color, shape, .etc)

 

[Cindi]

I like the Hudson. For me it has more personality.

 

[redheadedbeauty]

I like the Hudson. For me it has more personality.

Do you think it's a classic bag? (Will it still be "in" in a year or two?)