I got a tiffany sparklers necklace in parisolite for Christmas and love it. I knew I was getting it so I hinted for the earrings from my DH but he didn't get it. He did get me two stacking rings for around $600, a little more than the earrings would have been. The rings were DY and very similar to a DY I have, round pave, double shank, usually a stone in middle but mine is all pave diamonds. My problem is this my DH doesn't care if I return the rings but he wants me to buy something else from the store they were from because SA is a friend, I can get the earrings for my bday. I fell in love with a large cushion cut parisolite DY ring, but it's about $300 more. To me that's more of an anniversary/bday present, not Christmas(too many other expenses). The reason I described my ring is because that one also comes in parisolite for the right price but I don't want it because it's too similiar to the one I have. There were a couple other pieces I liked, but I loved the large DY ring. My DH says just get it, but I'm struggling with decision. What would you do?