I bought this bag for many reasons & I have lots of opinions about it! I'll share them with you!
PROS:
1. 7 Pockets total. All deep pockets. (I am very organized and never lose anything in this bag. Perfect!)
2. Single strap handle! (You won't have one strap falling off & the handle is so pretty)
3. Great quality & beautiful, of course
CONS:
1. Handle. (It doesn't bother me much because I have been carrying huge and heavy backpacks all my life... but I can understand why the strap would bother MANY people! The strap is round & with the size of the artsy and how much you would ideally carry in it... the weight drags on the shoulder and does hurt. For me, I would say it does hurt a little bit, but not enough to bother me and hate the purse. For many others, this is the case. ... for this reason, if you went with empreinte, this would be much less a problem)
2. Maintenance of the handle. (When I use this purse, I have to be very careful not to place it on certain hooks in bathroom stalls or it makes scratches or ugly dents in the leather handle... because the handle is thick! In this case, I honestly have to sometimes use the bathroom WITH the purse over my shoulder or ask someone to watch it for me. This is not enough reason for me to not like the purse though.. I just find this another thing I do for my Artsy.
... just keep in mind that with a galliera, this will probably be less of a problem.)
3. Sometimes little kids get curious and peek in my purse or go through it because it is always open. (this is not a big deal, but once in a while I leave the purse around the house for a small amount of time then find a little kid running around with my sunglasses or something! If the purse had closure, they'd be much less likely to go through it. I never had issues with kids going through my bags before. Since the bag is so big and very open when it is sitting down, it is easy to see inside. It's tempting for a little kid to look in.)
4. Open-bag problem again (I sometimes set my purse in the passenger seat... if the guy in front of me brakes suddenly, it has happened that my purse has tipped all the way over and my things fall out. Again, not a big deal, but something to think about)
5. Takes up room. (Not an issue for me, but the artsy has lots of FORM, which means that if you are out eating dinner or something, the bag kindof needs it's own spot to sit! Whereas for the galliera, it is flatter/thinner in shape and you could manage to sit next to it. My artsy takes just as much sitting room as I do. Maybe something to consider, especially if you have kids. I have never hung my artsy over a chair. It's impossible to set it behind you comfortably either. It would take up almost the whole chair. With previous bags, some were as big as the artsy, but would "lie down" which would make the purse desirable to carry on the lap. The artsy sitting on my lap makes me feel like there is a child on my lap or something, whereas other bags would feel like... a small puppy in comparison.)
I tried to think of all the things that posed problems for me with this purse that I never experienced with the many other bags I have owned. Things that I think maybe a person who doesn't own it may think are problems.
I do not own the galliera, but I would imagine that the strap is much more comfortable. But I wouldn't like it because I am a very organized person and in general, I just like the way the artsy looks!
If you don't need all the different pockets, I think the galliera would be great to have too. It's all about functionality and what works for you. Just because a lot of people like the artsy, doesn't mean that you can't like the galliera more! I love my artsy and would recommend it, but I can see exactly why it's not the purse for everyone.
Pick what's right for you!