I have the classic navy with silver hardware. I really love it.
When I picked mine up, they had the blue reissue with gold hardware. It was about $500 or $600 more, I think. I really fell it in love with it as well. If I would have been more prepared for the price difference, I may have gotten that one instead. I love that distressed leather look and it was a stunner.
I didn't vote in the poll even though I have the classic, because they're both so gorgeous. You would really have to see them together and make a decision.
The funny thing is, they had a black one with the gold hardware, and I didn't like it as much as the navy.