If I'm correct the tutle was a pin. And I love turtles too.A TURTLE??? AHHHHH! I NEED IT!
eBay: COACH LOOP LANYARD #5865 - Starfish (item 320057681314 end time Mar-03-07 18:55:47 PST)
This is a lanyard with a starfish on it. Is the key fob anything like this?