CELINE Luggage Tote: Envelope vs. Zip

Which 1?

  • Envelope

  • Zip (w/ curves)


Results are only viewable after voting.

purse-nality

SemiKindCharmedLife
O.G.
Nov 7, 2007
5,771
34
function aside, which style do you prefer? pls vote and share opinions! thanks thanks!

team> :P Vs. team> :oh:


attachment.php
attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • celine_zip.jpg
    celine_zip.jpg
    17.4 KB · Views: 6,163
  • celine_zip1.jpg
    celine_zip1.jpg
    115.3 KB · Views: 1,074
  • celine.luggage.envelope.jpg
    celine.luggage.envelope.jpg
    157.3 KB · Views: 3,918
Last edited:
attachment.php


attachment.php


attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • celine-boston-bag-celine-leo.jpg
    celine-boston-bag-celine-leo.jpg
    80.9 KB · Views: 4,071
  • Celine navy beige vanessa jackman.jpg
    Celine navy beige vanessa jackman.jpg
    2.9 KB · Views: 67,592
  • celine-con-celine-luggage-tote.jpg
    celine-con-celine-luggage-tote.jpg
    31.6 KB · Views: 64,859
it's not easy as I prefer the dark colors more, so from the pics alone, I lean towards the zip with curves. Both are nice, but that one seems to be more classy and still special.
 
ohkaaay... still undecided... i think some of you already know that i'm on the hunt for orange. so if orange, what ya think?


attachment.php



envelope is said to be a bright orange (a tad more yellow i think), while zip a muted one.
 

Attachments

  • celine_sidebyside.JPG
    celine_sidebyside.JPG
    62.2 KB · Views: 3,529
The zip, because the rest of the design is eye-catching enough, and there's only so much busy the bag needs. For me the envelope is "too much information," visually speaking. I understand about the envelope being functional, but in terms of sheer looks I like the zip much more.
 
Zip for moi! the bag is already unique on its own, for me the envelope style takes away the over all simplicity of the bag.. the zip makes it more mysterious...as I said the envelope and key tag can also be seen on the suhali line of LV and H...the zip makes the bag mysteriously chic! less is more all the way, besides you already got a pop of color going on given that you like it to be orange.
 
purse-nality, you know I won't be much help because I like both, but I have to admit that for the orange, I like the zipper version, but only because the leather is textured. Another item to consider - notice that on the envelope version, you have the snaps on the "wings". I like this added touch, but it does change the asthetic a bit and allows you to keep them intact or opened...
 
I prefer the envelope. I love the practicality of it. I also like that it can be locked with a key and I like the snaps so that the bag can keep its "wing" shape. My anthracite is the envelope version.
 
oooh... zip on the lead! more 'look' opinions pls! every say counts!


Zip for moi! the bag is already unique on its own, for me the envelope style takes away the over all simplicity of the bag.. the zip makes it more mysterious...as I said the envelope and key tag can also be seen on the suhali line of LV and H...the zip makes the bag mysteriously chic! less is more all the way, besides you already got a pop of color going on given that you like it to be orange.

good point!


purse-nality, you know I won't be much help because I like both, but I have to admit that for the orange, I like the zipper version, but only because the leather is textured. Another item to consider - notice that on the envelope version, you have the snaps on the "wings". I like this added touch, but it does change the asthetic a bit and allows you to keep them intact or opened...

oh, the snaps can be undone? that's great! thought it was fixed... ya, the grainy leather are less prone to scratches than envelope's smooth calf... :thinking:


I prefer the envelope. I love the practicality of it. I also like that it can be locked with a key and I like the snaps so that the bag can keep its "wing" shape. My anthracite is the envelope version.

mod pics pretty pleeezzzz!!! :flowers: