I am watching an eBay auction for a whiskey shoulder zip and it is heavily scratched. Do you think these are too deep to be rubbed out? If these can rubbed out I'd like to add a whiskey bag to my Legacy collection. Thanks!
From my own experience, which may be different from others, I would say the one near the turn lock might be hard to rub out. I haven't had any luck rubbing scratches on the more solid parts of my bags - strap, by the locks, etc for some reason. Mine came with a couple of scratches that I've never been able to rub out. Though I'm adding my own to it anyway.
And I agree the scratches and weathered look adds to the bag. But if you will find them annoying I would stay away from whiskey and go for white.
I got my whiskey bag "as is" from the outlet b/c it was "shop worn" (read: already darkened a bit with a lot of scratches). It looks awesome - the deep scratches do rub out (though I agree with luvmycoach about the ones on the more "solid" parts of the bag not rubbing out as easily), sometimes not completely, but they "lighten" considerably. I have also noticed that the more handling the bag gets, the more the scratches rub out. I also love the weathered look of this leather - I'm completely anal about scratches and things on my bags, but I truly don't sweat them with the whiskey b/c it just adds to the appeal!