Keep the Madison carryall or get the Brooke?

[Kristen]

I just got the Madison, but I am eyeing the Brooke, and I can't decide if I should exchange the Madison. I love the slouchyness (is that even a word? lol) of the Brooke, which I guess is why Im leaning towards it.

Does anyone have modeling pictures of the Brooke? Oh and I am eyeing the large one, so it will be an even exchange. TIA

 

[Cate14]

No modeling pictures, but if you love slouchy, go for the Brooke. The leather is soft and scrumptious. I have 2 Brookes, both large, and they are very unstructured. Good luck with your decision!

 

[CrazyBaker]

I just got the large Brooke last week and love it. I just finished a big cake project so I'm covered in sugar right now but if you want, I can take a modeling picture tomorrow.

 

[shalomnurse]

I recently bought a large Brooke, and I find that it is not large enough for me. I prefer the Madison Carryall. Just my two cents,

 

[Kristen]

I recently bought a large Brooke, and I find that it is not large enough for me. I prefer the Madison Carryall. Just my two cents,

I just compared the measurements, and I think you may be right. I haven't even worn her yet, so maybe I should just wear her and love her

 

[shalomnurse]

I already have the Madison Carryall in bone leather, but I am thinking I may get the same Op Art one that you have. I love it. The grey is gorgeous.

 

[kmk752]

I really like the grey one you already have... it is just gorgeous!!!

 

[Kristen]

I really like the grey one you already have... it is just gorgeous!!!

Thank you, it is a gorgeous color, even better in person. I think I may just keep her. If its meant for me to have the Brooke, I'll get her

 

[PurseKindaGal]

keep your lovely carryall I like her

 

[coachmommyofmin]

I have the large brooke and she's my most favorite bag! I thought for a while that she may be over-whealming me with her size, but today i was wearing her and realized that she's just perfect for my situation (2 little kids), and decided to keep her. I have the large black leather one.

 

[Kristen]

Well now I have to keep her, because I snipped the tags so I can use her later on today. I figure if it's meant for me to have the brooke, I'll get her one day