Seasonal colour/color analysis and (applying it to one's wardrobe and makeup choices) seems to be very popular at the moment.
I thought we could have a thread to discuss different systems, the pluses and the minuses. Even whether you think it's all hocus-pocus.
I've studied art, and there was a lot of colour theory (I recommend Patrick Baty's The Anatomy of Colour and The Book of Colour Concepts (Taschen)). Pure colour science and theory (7) and applied (semiotics) is not really what I want to talk about here, although it's related. I want to explore the colour systems that explore harmony for style and wardrobe.
Some of the 4/12 seasonal theory doesn't make sense in practice but it's better than someone giving me only 5 colours to wear.
I've been 'diagnosed' twice, both times using the same 12 season theory (the 'draping' was done differently). The first time I was told I was a 'Soft Autumn' the last time a 'Bright Spring' (I'm not asking for a diagnosis - I don't particularly like any of the palettes exclusively). As you can imagine, I am near neutral - but high colour (peach). My take is that what suits me suits me, what doesn't, doesn't. If I know what I should stay away from (taupes, mushrooms, ice-blue, rich cream, Barbie pink, dark magenta, most pastels/dusties etc) then I'm fine with the rest.
I'm not against consultations. I think it's (mostly) money well spent so long as the consultant doesn't tell you to ditch your entire wardrobe and buy a new one (as was the case of another friend). Anything that gives us more insight into ourselves is great. I really enjoyed looking at myself more objectively. I always though 'peach undertone' meant very warm, now I understand I'm almost neutral (as much 'pink' as 'yellow') a lot of things make sense (looking awful in strong creams or warm beige for instance).
In terms of theory into practice, I think anything works really well if someone is typical, especially in the extreme, but not so easy if you don't fit. People with olive (my sister) peach (me) purple (my friend) also don't lean 'warm = yellow / cool = pink. And since when did red/pink become cool colours? My taps beg to differ.
I know there are a lot of different systems out there too. I know there's one that basically just says don't go darker than your darkest colour, no lighter than your lightest, use your lip colour for your 'hottest look' etc. There there are others that use digital analysis of one's skin and harmonise shapes for patterns and details of the wardrobe/jewellery as well as colour.
I just wondered if others have had experience in terms of consultations with any o the systems, and what you did as a result? If you diagnosed yourself? If you did more than one, which systems work(ed) best? Or whether you think the whole thing is a scam?