^that's tough! the conteen will probably fit more, like notebooks and papers, as mentioned earlier, and can also be held over the shoulder which makes it somewhat more convenient when u want the hands-free option...but the edith is just so cute and seems to be shaped kind of similar to the LV speedy in size and when you look at it from the side... what do you plan to use the bag for? Also, if you prefer whisky color, then you should go for the conteen, whereas the edith loaf is now only available in chocolate...!