Which one should I get?

  1. Hello everybody, I have been debating over these two handbags for a long time and I can't decide which one to get. I'm new to this forum so I'm going to try to figure out how to put the pictures up here so I'm sorry if they don't show up.
    The Signiture Gallery Tote
    Coach - SIGNATURE GALLERY TOTE

    or the Legacy Leather Shoulder bag
    Coach - LEGACY LEATHER SHOULDER BAG

    Which color also? I'm so indecisive (I don't know if I spelled that right) Thanks for your opinions in advanced!
     
  2. i don't think you can go wrong with the shoulder bag...
    and the color is up to you...it depends on what might go with your wardrobe.
     
  3. Get the Legacy shoulder bag....as for color alot of people get whiskey. But, it's totally up to you, I like the white personally.
     

  4. i agree completely! it's a gorgeous bag! i would get it in white too but if ya are gonna use it daily, perhaps the whiskey?
     
  5. My vote is for the shoulder bag!
     
  6. Legacy!!
     
  7. like everyone else, legacy!

    unless you have a back problem or shoulder problem, then the gallery tote will probably be better since it will be just as heavy as the legacy bag when it's filled..but the legacy bag isn't. (ok, maybe a bit exaggerated)
     
  8. the legacy too!
    prob in either whisky or black :smile:
     
  9. I like the Legacy Shoulder Bag. It will fit a lot more than you'd think it would and it's a great style. For me, the Gallery Tote is just too large. So it would depend on how large a bag you would need. Plus the Legacy bag has extra compartments that make organizing your bag much easier and neater. :smile:
     
  10. I love the shoulder bag. Get a color that you think you can get good use of.
     
  11. Legacy!
     
  12. I would definantely go with the second bag in white!! very classic, cool, sophisticated and will match everything!! The first one is cute, but yells COACH, and plus, the white bag would look nice with a colorful scarf attached to it!
     
  13. i guess i'm the minority here....but i like the first one.
     
  14. I'm with you on that! I like the Ali but not so much the shoulder bag for the legacy.
     
  15. I like the first one too, only because I was just at Coach this afternoon and tried on the shoulder bag. I quickly realized that for me, it would be a pain to get things in and out of while it's being worn/carried.

    But then my personal preference is for bags with two handles that can be carried in hand or on the elbow. So you should factor that in as well.

    I bought the Legacy satchel instead :biggrin: :biggrin: